Slice of Bourbon Pecan Pie

A Guide to Ordering Your Holiday Pies

By: Abby A, Pie Bar Marietta

Happy Holidays! Pie Bar's Christmas orders are officially open! Our menu is limited, like our Thanksgiving menu, but with new flavors!

Our flavors for sweet Christmas pies are:
- Apple Streusel
- Bourbon Pecan
- Salted Peanut Butter Cup
- Cranberry & Orange Custard
- Key Lime
- Bourbon Chocolate Pecan

All those flavors are to die for! Apple Streusel and Bourbon Pecan are classics! Cranberry Orange Custard is a nice winter flavor, and Key Lime and Salted Peanut Butter Cup are big hits in our shops! It's a great selection this year. Now let's check out savories!

Our frozen products will include:
- Rosemary Chicken Pot Pie (10")
- Roasted Veggie Pot Pie (10")
- Shepherd's Pie
- Bacon, Cheddar, and Chives Quiche
- Spinach, Feta, and Red Pepper Quiche
- Vanilla Ice Cream Pints

Personally, I think a quiche would be a great addition to your Christmas morning! The Bacon and Cheddar quiche is our most popular quiche; it makes for a great breakfast or brunch! the Rosemary Chicken Pot Pie is our most popular pot pie, and it's an amazing, cozy winter dinner. We also have pints of locally crafted Butter and Cream Vanilla Ice Cream! Makes a great addition to pies like Apple, Pecan, or Brown Sugar Chess.

Now, let's talk about ordering these delicious pies. all of our Christmas orders go through There will be a Christmas tab, which you'll click on to get to the limited Christmas menu. When you add your pies to the cart, make sure all pies say "Christmas" in parentheses. This will ensure that all orders are for Christmas. If not all items in the cart are labeled "(Christmas)", then the website will not allow you to check out.

When you add your pies to the cart and you are finished with your selection, make sure to select the correct pickup location, either Marietta or Woodstock. You will select a time between 11 am and 6 pm Monday through Thursday, 12 pm and 4 pm for Sunday, or 11 am to 8 pm for Friday. These dates will be December 18th through the 23rd. Make sure to select the time that works best for you for the most efficient pickup process. 

When you've selected your time and date for pickup, it will lead you to the contact information page. You will enter your email, first and last name, and phone number. After that you've completed your order, you will receive a confirmation email to the one you provided on the contact information page. 

That's it! Your Christmas order is placed and will be ready for pickup on the day you selected! If there are any issues with your order, like changing a pie or the pickup time/date, please respond to your confirmation email BEFORE Friday, December 16th at 9 pm. After that, we cannot make any changes to your order. 

Walk-ins will be available the week of Christmas, but there is no guarantee that the flavor you desire will be in the case later in the day. Since there is a large volume of pickup orders, we have limited walk-in orders. That's why we highly, highly, HIGHLY recommend placing preorders. It saves the stress of needing a pie but not having the guarantee of getting it. We will post on our social media every morning of that week what walk-ins we have. If we have the pie in the shop that day, you can call on that day ONLY to place a pre-order for pickup THAT DAY. We will require payment over the phone. 

Christmas is a huge time of year for us, and we're so excited to serve you! 

Thank you for taking the time to listen to my guide! I hope everyone has an amazing holiday season!

Back to blog